There is a lot of talk in the national newspapers and TV about the two-speed economy: the mining industry that is doing well and the rest of us, doing not so well.
Here on the Gold Coast we seem to have a three-speed economy: the mining industry, the Council and the rest of us. Seems like while the mining industry boom along in other regions of our state and our Nation, the only industry doing well on the Gold Coast is the Council.
I’m in a local business and like a lot of local businesses we have had to tighten our belts and reign in spending to survive the downturn in the economy generally and the tourism industry specifically. Seems that tightening of belts requirement has not reached Gold Coast City Council.
The most interesting document obtained the long-term financial outlook. It’s on my website now for anyone to download. For transparency sake, I think that all the council meeting agendas be online long before the meetings are scheduled and the minutes should be online in the following week of the meeting for all interested residents to see. Ultimately I would like to see council meetings streamed to the internet so that a cheap but permanent copy is retained about what was said by whom. I have witnessed myself things said during Council meetings being different to what is presented to the media later on.
The long-term financial outlook Council is bleak.
We will be in deficit in 2012-13 to the tune of $26 million. 2013-14 sees that add another $40 million. $29 million for 2014-15 and $13 million for 2015-16. That is over $100 million of deficits for the next term of Council locked in for whomever wins the next Council elections. This is not counting the $50 householder pork barreling that Councillors pushed through before the next election. There is no money for this $50 cheque to go to every household – it’s just borrowed money. We as a city are borrowing millions just to pay ourselves $50 each!
These deficits also point to the fact that Council is locking itself into general rate rises of 5.5% from 2013 onwards and a fee and charges increase of 5% per annum compounding. AllConnex disbandment is being lined up to get all the blame but I feel it is Council itself that should be taking a good hard look at itself. It hasn’t made the cuts it should have as the economy down turns just like every other business had to on the Gold Coast to survive.
The figures presented are sometimes contradictory and other figures are downright disturbing. For example on page one of the long-term financial plan the discussion details how the Council’s budget will be in deficit for the next four years at least. Yet on the very next page one of the assumptions is that “The model assumes the budget will produce an annual surplus of $15m”. We have recently seen announcements of budget surpluses but as far as I can see we have been borrowing for building assets that won’t provide a return. That’s deficit spending in my book.
Another inconsistency I discovered was the money that the city has borrowed for projects that are no longer going ahead. According to the Mayor’s speech at the Institute of Business Leader’s budget prelaunch breakfast, Council has borrowed a lot of money it doesn’t need right at the moment. But rather than bring down the debt we at the breakfast were told that officers report that the city is making more money from interest revenue. I found that strange at the breakfast and yep – the document shows how this is not the case. We receive around 5.5% interest revenue and pay 7.0%pa on borrowings.
In the last budget in 2008 our city had borrowings of around $265 million. In 2012 that will top at $850 million and be almost $1 billion dollars of debt by 2015! There is a lot of talk about Net Debt however our city seems to be borrowing or drawing down against our ‘home loan’ and then just putting that money in the bank.
The State Government financial benchmarks are all being missed now with this Council. Working Capital Ratio should be between 1 and 4. It will be 4.3 in 2011-12. The Operating Surplus Ratio should be no more than 10%. It will break that barrier in 2017. Our net financial liabilities ratio should be between 0% – 60%. Well next year we break that barrier for the first time and it will read 95% by 2014-15. The interest coverage ratio should be between 0% – 5%, for the next few years it will be between 7% and 8%. The Asset sustainability ratio shouldn’t be less than 90% according to the State Government. This is 66% next year and is falling rapidly to 39% in 2014-15.
Yep. These are highly technical accounting terms and ratios but in business they are the indicators of a healthy or unhealthy business. If Council was a traded stock the rating would be “SELL”! As it says in the report in black and white “Council does not meet the benchmark for these ratios until 2020″ – almost 10 years from now!
Seems Council has gambled on AllConnex bring home the bacon, reinvesting the compensation from the State Government for all the bulk water and distribution assets we gave up and reinvested them into a distribution business we already owned but now we don’t control.
The most damning line in the report is that “Council is raising sufficient operating revenue to meet operating expenses”. Even the way this line is written indicates how the Council wants Councillors to respond – to raise rates. Never is there any suggestion that drastic cuts need to be made nor is there any line that the council itself needs to reform.
Costs are out of control and so is debt creeping up to unsustainable levels. It won’t be long before we are a basket case like the Queensland State Government who is now suffering under an interest bill of $100 million each and every week!
To get out of this mess we need to reform council, cut the 8 directorates to 5, refocus them on core Council responsibilities and defer many of the ‘make work’ projects, reports, committees, task forces and unproductive activities the this Council seems to be doing these days. Tough minded business people need to take over in Council to turn this ship around otherwise we will be a failed city by 2016.

The headline said it all: “Junket Junkies”.
..it’s time to have your say!
The Gold Coast City Council Budget for 2011-12 released last month showed that our city’s gross debt levels rising to over a billion dollars, if you include AllConnex, by 2015. But Gold Coasters shouldn’t feel especially worried, not when we compare ourselves to the overall debt position of our State of Queensland. That’s what people should really be worried about!
It’s that time of year again. The one you either love or loathe, TAX TIME!
We are not competitive as a city. We don’t encourage business to move here and we certainly don’t encourage start-ups to start up here. It’s our basic costs, regulations, laws, planning scheme and fees that is killing our economy and that’s what is killing us as a city.
